Councillor should debate the policy, not the person

IT is beyond my comprehension to believe the level to which Coun Andrews stooped last week in launching his very personal and unprovoked attack on me through your paper.

His letter only serves to demonstrate how difficult it is to engage in a reasoned and intelligent debate.

Even “well-meaning members of the community” know that it is by debating the policy and not the person that the work of council is progressed.

My decisions and subsequent votes have always been made with integrity and by taking into account all relevant considerations.

I must, however, point out to your readers that one of the votes I was credited with making occurred before I was even elected to council in 2011.

It is notable that at this time, the council had no one-group majority, so we may surmise that the vote of an Independent member would carry more weight than in the present situation.

Not being privy to the debate in question, one has to wonder why Coun Andrews was unable to influence this decision.

Perhaps we could take a clue from a debate I was party to at last Tuesday’s council meeting, where in discussing the complex financial implications of maintaining closed churchyards, he chose to use his three-minute speaking slot to lead the council down a cul-de-sac, moving the topic into a prolonged and irrelevant discussion on pagodas in Japan and China.

Perhaps in selecting a representative for our community, it would be wise and effective to select one who can competently deliver his point to the intended target, instead of one who is only capable of delivering a series of own-goals.

Janet Sanderson, Thornton-le-Dale

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

3:30pm Wed 28 Nov 12

twotonethomas says...

Oh dear Cllr Sanderson.

Your last letter, when you dishonestly claimed that Independent Councillors walked out of a meeting, proved you to be a liar.

Now you use this letter, in which you condemn 'debating the person', to attack Councillor Andrews rather than his arguments, to prove that you are also an hypocrite.

A liar and a hypocrite, no wonder you stood for the tories rather than as an Independent :)
Oh dear Cllr Sanderson. Your last letter, when you dishonestly claimed that Independent Councillors walked out of a meeting, proved you to be a liar. Now you use this letter, in which you condemn 'debating the person', to attack Councillor Andrews rather than his arguments, to prove that you are also an hypocrite. A liar and a hypocrite, no wonder you stood for the tories rather than as an Independent :) twotonethomas
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree