Bryant ‘very close’ to intervening over Stormont budget impasse

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Northern Ireland Secretary Sir Chris Bryant said he believes it is coming “very, very close” to the moment where he will have to set a budget for the region to avoid a “public sector crisis”.

The Secretary of State told the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee he did not want to “bring down the Executive” but warned he may also have to consider taking new powers over the introduction of revenue-raising measures.

Sir Chris told MPs that Stormont’s lawful expenditure would run out “fairly soon” as he accused devolved ministers of being “commentators” rather than “players making decisions”.

Northern Ireland Affairs Committee
The Northern Ireland Affairs Committee was holding an evidence session (UK Parliament/PA)

But Stormont Finance Minister John O’Dowd responded by accusing the Secretary of State of responding to facts with “bluster and theatrics”.

Ministers in Belfast have said they cannot strike a budget for 2026/27 without additional financial support from the Treasury.

The UK Government has offered about £1.5 billion in extra funding over the next three years, with £525 million delivered this year, in an effort to help balance the books – but Stormont’s leaders have said that is not enough.

Last month’s UK Budget allocated a further £131 million of extra funding to Northern Ireland in the current financial year and a total of £270 million across three years.

Stormont departments are currently operating on contingency budgets of 95% of last year’s spend.

Asked to provide an update on budget negotiations with Stormont ministers, Sir Chris told MPs: “Stasis. Nothing.”

He said: “People keep on telling me they want more money, they want more money, they want more money, and I can’t say it in a clearer way than that there is no more money.

“We have made a full and final offer. That’s all there is.”

The Secretary of State said there were a number of other issues he wanted to engage in “but I can’t get past this first stage of getting a budget sorted”.

Sinn Fein finance minister John O’Dowd
Stormont Finance Minister John O’Dowd accused the Secretary of State of responding to facts with ‘bluster and theatrics’ (Claudia Savage/PA)

He added: “In the end, the only people who have the legal responsibility for setting a budget is the Northern Ireland Executive.

“This is one of the symbols of the kind of complete abnormality that now seems to pervade Northern Ireland politics.

“And there’s a bit of me that just wants to say: ‘Everybody’s got to get real.’”

Committee chair Tonia Antoniazzi asked how much more money the Stormont ministers required.

Sir Chris said: “Oh, I mean, it changes every week. One version is another billion pounds.

“I think the latest version from John O’Dowd on Monday was one-and-a-half billion pounds this year.”

The minister said he had tried to “adjudicate” between parties in the powersharing Executive.

The fall-out from the recent Drumcree parading dispute has soured relations between Sinn Féin and the DUP.

Sir Chris said: “I’ve tried processes of adjudicating between the different parties because, let’s face it, the parties aren’t talking to each other at the moment, won’t sit in the same room as each other.

“We’ve got a situation where neither the First Minister nor the deputy First Minister was even able to attend Remembrance Sunday, or for that matter, the National Economic Council with the Prime Minister.

“And you would have thought that that was a key moment where everybody would want to say: ‘Let’s stand up for Northern Ireland in all the conversations about devolution and making the economy work for the whole of the United Kingdom.’”

He added: “I think it’s a very odd system, where you have a series of meetings with different political parties, and they all go out and do a press conference beforehand, and they basically say: ‘I’m going to tell him what’s what.’ And then afterwards they have another press conference in which they say: ‘I told him what’s what.’

North Belfast stabbing
Ulster Unionist MP Robin Swann asked Sir Chris if he would intervene to set a budget (Liam McBurney/PA)

“That isn’t a way to negotiate.

“It turns all the politicians in Northern Ireland into commentators on politics, rather than actually players making decisions, and that’s what we need.”

Ulster Unionist MP Robin Swann warned about upcoming industrial action among health workers who have not received a pay uplift.

He asked: “If the current impasse between the political parties can’t be resolved… will you take the stance and the position and actually bring forward a budget?”

Sir Chris said the crisis Mr Swann had warned about in terms of industrial action “is potentially going to get considerably worse”.

He said Stormont ministers’ “lawful expenditure will run out fairly soon” with no budget in place.

He said schools and hospitals would stay open “but a lot of elective and other work would simply not be able to proceed”.

Northern Ireland Affairs Committee
Sir Chris was being questioned by MPs about the budget impasse (UK Parliament/PA)

Sir Chris said: “Somebody would have to be making decisions about what cannot happen in February and March in Northern Ireland, and that is a kind of public service crisis which I’m desperate to avoid.

“I haven’t got a plan at the moment to introduce a budget, but I’m not shy of my responsibilities, if that’s something that I end up having to do.”

Pressed again by Mr Swann on whether he would intervene directly, the Northern Ireland Secretary said: “I’m not trying to avoid the question, it’s just that I haven’t come to that moment yet, but we are very conscious that we can’t let this run on forever and a day.

“It’s not just about this financial year. If there’s no budget in place before the end of this financial year, they literally can’t spend anything next year, including their own receipts.

“So there has to be a budget in place.”

Conservative committee member Simon Hoare asked Sir Chris what his “trigger” was for intervening to set a budget himself.

The minister said: “It is absolutely unprecedented for the Westminster government to set a budget over the heads of the Executive, and they have told me thus far that they don’t want me to do so, and I don’t want to.

Stormont
Stormont ministers have been unable to set a budget (Liam McBurney/PA)

“And I don’t want to bring down the Executive, but I think we are very, very close to a moment where we are going to have absolutely no choice, in the interests of the people of Northern Ireland.”

Sir Chris then said he could not order ministers to introduce revenue-raising measures in Northern Ireland “without taking very significant new powers”.

He said: “The very fact that I’m mentioning it is obviously something that means that it’s the kind of thing that we are, we do have to think about.

“But I believe in devolution. I want devolution to work.”

Sir Chris continued: “There’s a phrase in the book of Common Prayer about marriage which shouldn’t be entered into lightly and without serious consideration, and that is also true of taking powers to the Secretary of State, which I don’t really want to do because I believe in devolution.

“But if we have to, then we have to.”

Mr O’Dowd said: “Chris Bryant continues to respond to cold, hard facts and figures with bluster and theatrics.

Drumcree Orange Order parade
Mr O’Dowd accused Sir Chris of ‘not listening’ (Rebecca Black/PA)

“All the more interesting is that the cold, hard facts I have provided, use figures from his Government, provided by the Treasury.

“As I outlined in the Assembly chamber yesterday, departments and ministers have been engaging extensively with Westminster since February of this year when the open book exercise was conducted.

“Departments have provided detailed evidence on financial pressures, action taken to generate savings and transformation plans. There have also been several rounds of talks at Hillsborough.

“Actions continue to be taken to address the funding gap and pressures are reducing, but a significant gap remains.”

He said: “Unfortunately, despite repeated evidence that the figures are unworkable, the Secretary of State is still not listening.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos